What Would Save the Euro?

Popular Economics Weekly

Now that Greece has voted NO on the latest European Commission-European Central Bank-IMF proposal (the so-called troika), will Greece stay in the Eurozone? If so, Greece may save the euro.

Why is this choice even necessary when most economists know the solution to their problems—something that would be a combination of easing the most draconian conditions that have really been imposed on all EU and Eurozone members, and a European version of our Marshall Plan that would reinvest in productive capacity to bring back growth to those countries suffering most from the worst recession since the Great Depression.

And isn’t just Greece. As Paul Krugman’s most recent Op-eds have asserted, countries from Finland to Spain to the Netherlands are also suffering from too much austerity—austerity in the sense of focusing too much on cutting spending and raising taxes to pay down the debt accumulated mostly from the Great Recession, when more spending is needed to speed up economic recovery—which is the only proven way to pay down debts.

Graph: Trading Economics

“The truth is that Europe’s self-styled technocrats are like medieval doctors who insisted on bleeding their patients — and when their treatment made the patients sicker, demanded even more bleeding. A “yes” vote in Greece would have condemned the country to years more of suffering under policies that haven’t worked and in fact, given the arithmetic, can’t work: austerity probably shrinks the economy faster than it reduces debt, so that all the suffering serves no purpose.”

It is a dilemma brought on mostly by the EU’s massive bureaucracy that rules almost every facet of EU life. One commentator said the regulations that must be satisfied to join the EU would rise to 5 feet if stacked vertically.

Included in those requirements are economic policies—such as budget deficits cannot exceed three percent. Another condition even more draconian is an inflation target of 2 percent. It is mainly a German condition from their past. It brings back the horror of economic collapse that led to Hitler and the Holocaust. Yet without a higher and more flexible inflation target, sustainable growth cannot happen. The recovery from GW Bush’s first recession only happened with massive deficit spending and a 5 percent inflation rate at one time.

The horror of hyperinflation is really no longer possible in a modern world so interlinked by trade and finance (and modern technology that produces anything required cheaply and quickly). We suffer from oversupply of goods and services, in other words, that makes deflation the most real danger.

In fact, Japanese-style deflation has been more the norm since the 1980s, since then Fed Chairman Volcker’s focus on austerity (in the form of sky-high interest rates) to bring down America’s sky-high inflation of the early 1980s.

Then why isn’t there more discussion among the ‘troika’ of debt relief, which seems to be Greece’s main problem? The austerity policies foisted on Greece by the troika has put Greece into a major depression, with 25 percent unemployment and a 25 percent reduction in its economic growth. And nothing but higher and sustained growth can ever pay down the huge mountain of debt—some $323 billion at last count—owed to its creditors. But to allow that to happen Greece’s debt load must be eased in some way.

Columbia University economist Jeffrey Sachs, a specialist in economic development, has lamented Germany’s insistence on adhering to agreed upon ‘rules’, rather than allowing more flexibility in Greece’s debt repayment terms.

“Sovereign debts have been restructured hundreds, perhaps thousands, of times – including for Germany. In fact, hardline demands by the country’s US government creditors after World War I contributed to deep financial instability in Germany and other parts of Europe, and indirectly to the rise of Adolf Hitler in 1933. After World War II, however, Germany was the recipient of vastly wiser concessions by the US government, culminating in consensual debt relief in 1953, an action that greatly benefitted Germany and the world. Yet Germany has failed to learn the lessons of its own history.”

And we know what happens when history repeats itself. Even Germany has to know. So saving Greece is important for a number of reasons--not just European unity. Foremost is the need to reform an unworkable system, to make it more flexible, with plans that would be already in place to aid countries that have suffered the most from the Great Recession--which lest we forget, was almost a repeat of the Great Depression.

Harlan Green © 2015

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen

Where is the Inflation?

Financial FAQs

If we would listen to the Europeans advocating austerity measures to punish Greece and Italy in particular for their profligacy, then inflation is right around the corner, according to the Germans, at least. Germany’s Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaubele is the most hawkish in advocating that the Greeks won’t get the next installment of their rescue package unless they shave off 130M euros in spending cuts to bring down their some 400M euros in debt.

Herr Schaubele is the principal advocate of what Paul Krugman calls the “confidence fairy”. The confidence fairy is the myth that too much debt causes the loss of confidence in a sovereign currency, driving up interest rates and inflation, even during recessions. It is the rationalization extreme fiscal conservatives use to justify their ideology that all debt is bad (though it is their wealthy supporters who do the most lending), and so debtors must be punished for their borrowing.

That is behind Herr Schaubele’s attempts to drive Greece out of the euro by insisting on such draconian austerity measures that Greece cannot possibly fulfill. Herr Schaubele’s efforts have succeeded instead in pulling several EU countries back into recession, as prices and output are falling, which is what one would expect, because such austerity measures cause a huge drop in incomes, and so any stimulus to grow economies. Great Britain, Ireland, Italy the Netherlands, and Spain are just a few countries suffering from its effects.

“We doubt that the euro zone will be able to avoid further contraction in the first quarter and very possibly the second as well in the face of tighter credit conditions, a further tightening in fiscal policy in many countries, the ongoing pressures facing consumers (high and rising unemployment, and still squeezed purchasing power) and limited global growth,” said Howard Archer, chief European economist at IHS Global Insight, said in a Marketwatch interview.

Economists have been discussing the dangers of inflation since the beginning of economics, but don’t really spell out that there are at least 2 kinds of inflation. There is consumer inflation measured by such as the Consumer Price Index, and there are many commodity price indexes that measure asset inflation.

Graph: Econoday

Consumer price inflation was nonexistent in December at the headline and core levels. The consumer price index in December was unchanged for the second month in a row with lower energy costs playing a key role. Excluding food and energy, the core CPI decelerated to a modest 0.1 percent increase after gaining 0.2 percent in November, and is up just 2.2 percent year-over-year. 

Graph: The World Bank

For the U.S., commodity prices are best measured by the U.S. Producer Price Index for producer goods, which at the producer level in December was tugged down by gasoline and food costs but the core was warmer than expected.  Producer prices edged down 0.1 percent after rebounding 0.3 percent the prior month.

The two are not necessarily related, because producers cannot always pass on their costs to consumers, though economists still take sides. The so-called monetarists, or neo-classicists tend to be fiscal, small government conservatives that believe all economic activity depends on the size of the money supply. And government should not be in the business of boosting the money supply with stimulus, which only causes more inflation.

Whereas Keynesians, or neo-Keynesians, believe that there is really no danger of inflation as long as unemployment is high, which happens during recessions. That’s because consumers who power some 67 percent of aggregate demand cannot create inflationary pressures as long as personal incomes, wages and salaries and the like are stagnant.

In fact, Keynesians maintain from their Great Depression experience that the overall money supply doesn’t increase during recessions, but is hoarded, causing deflationary pressures. And deflation is the hardest to root out, as Japan found out since their bubbles burst in 1990. In fact, corporations are the largest hoarders of cash (some $2 trillion to date), so don’t expect much hiring from them.

Yet, it is really small businesses that provide 70 percent of new hires, so that is where we should look for jobs’ improvement. A good measure of small business is the National Federation of Business Optimism Index, which hasn’t yet risen above recession levels. But the jobs market is tightening, in line with U.S. overall improved employment.

“Reports of workforce reductions are at their lowest level since October 2007,” said the latest NFIB report. “Forty-one percent of owners hired or tried to hire in the past three months, but 31 percent reported few or no qualified applicants for the position(s). The increase in the percent of owners with hard to fill job openings indicates that job markets are tightening somewhere, and correctly anticipated a decline in the unemployment rate.”

So beware of the confidence fairies, says Nobelist Paul Krugman. If you believe in them, you will surely lose confidence in the very institutions that create economic growth.

Harlan Green © 2012