Equality Is Good For Everyone!

Answering Kennedy’s Call

“And on the tax front, it’s time for rich people like me to pay more.” Mitt Romney

Getty/Bettmann

This quote from a recent NYTimes Mitt Romney Op-ed is my Christmas message: Equal opportunity hasn’t been available to many Americans, even though it is part of the American Dream—America is the land of opportunity that is taught in schools and heard by immigrants.

Why? Because it’s a larger economic truth that not all Americans have accepted. Equality is good for everyone. It should be self-evident, a statement of common sense. The more equality of opportunity among us, the more we can better ourselves, become more productive citizens, which in turn increases our national wealth (and lowers budget deficits).

It was certainly the dream of immigrants, such as my mother, a British citizen born in Jamaica.

But there are times such as today when many Americans don’t believe it is possible, which is why we are living in another Gilded Age with the worst income inequality of the developed world. It is on a par with developing countries in Africa and has been the major cause of recessions and the Great Depression.

Many have bought the counter narrative by those that don’t like equality, such as Donald Trump and his MAGA supporters, part of the privileged few at the top of the income ladder who want us to believe they are the most qualified to create greater wealth for the rest of us.

This Gilded Age was formed like the last Gilded Age of President William McKinley, from a concentration of power among the wealthiest oligarchs. Then it was monopolies in such as the newly created railroad and oil industries.

Today, it is small government policies of Donald Trump that mirror the trickle-down economic policies of President Reagan because enough Americans believed it, believed government was the problem and cutting taxes the solution, believed that equality is not good for everyone because we live in a zero-sum world with limited resources. What is given to one must be taken from another.

The conservative position espoused by 1970s Economist Arthur Okun, for instance, was that greater equality meant less market efficiencies to produce and so fewer incentives for greater wealth, since leveling the playing field meant leveling out the opportunity for large profits.

But that has never been the case. There has always been copious evidence that the opposite is true; that overly large profits have led to diminished household wealth and breakup of communities.

One can measure inequality with such as the CIA’s World Factbook that ranks inequality among nations. Those with the greatest equality also have less violence, greater freedoms, greater health, and guaranteed vacations!

Richard Wilkinson’s TEDx lecture and book with Kate Pickett, “The Spirit Level” is one of the best studies of the dire effects of income inequality on the quality of life. The most important factor, and a sign of dire consequences when inequality has approached the level of the Great Depression, are the US violent crime and incarceration rates, which Wilkinson discusses at length.

The U.S. is by far the most violent country in the world—worse than any other developed country with the highest incarceration rates. Efforts to reverse such inequality have begun on the local levels, even if congressional conservatives have blocked raising the miniscule national minimum wage of $7.25 per hour that was last set in 2009.

It is worth just $5 per hour today whereas blue states like California and Connecticut have raised their minimum wage to $16.90 per hour in line with rising livings costs.

And there is an increasing awareness of the income disparities, such as the fact that corporate CEOs now earn more than 300 times the income of their employees, and certain hedge fund managers have reported an annual income of $1 billion.

The Center for American Progress launched the Washington Center For Equitable Growth, which aims to deepen the economic critique of inequality. It was set up by Berkeley economist Emmanuel Saez, among others, who is known with his partner Thomas Piketty as the first economists to historically research the history of income distribution over the past 100 years.

The mission statement of the Center explains why it is needed:

“New research suggests that growing inequality in the United States may have broad social and economic effects — by reducing stable demand for goods and services, dampening entrepreneurialism, undermining the inclusiveness and responsiveness of political and economic institutions, limiting access to education, and stunting individual development. Yet our understanding of how these mechanisms interact with the broader economy is limited.”

Mitt Romney’s Op-ed has voiced one of the major issues confronting Americans today—how to fix the overwhelming federal debt load that threatens the ‘full faith and credit’ of the U.S. government.

“The largest source of additional tax revenues is also probably the most compelling for the fairness and social stability. Some call it closing a tax code loophole but the term “loopholes” grossly understates their scale. “Caverns” or “caves” would be more fitting,” said Romney

Donald Trump’s flailing attempts to use higher tariffs to pay down federal debt, when it is in fact another tax on all Americans, is maybe the most important reason to follow Mitt Romney’s advice.

Taxing the wealthiest that haven’t been “paying their fair share”—including Donald Trump’s billionaire supporters, would close one of the largest loopholes that is endangering the U.S. economy, as Senator Bernie Sanders continually reminds us.

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen

A Place of Tolerance and Understanding

 Answering Kennedy’s Call

“I believe our political divide can be repaired. But our leaders must act with moral clarity and take their cues from the good people of this nation, who in times of tragedy always seem to find our better angels.” Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro

Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro wrote the above appeal just days after an arsonist invaded and attempted to burn down the Governor’s residence. Governor Shapiro attributed the attack to “the political division and violence in America today.”

He also gave thanks for the good people, whose “…prayers, blessings and messages of support we’ve received have lifted us up and shown us the way forward in the wake of a traumatic event.”

How do we find the “better angels” of our nature; was there a time when Americans were less partisan, more united in purpose?

There are many explanations and explainers of the political divide that led to red states vs. blue states and Donald Trump’s re-election. A major economic reason was the migration of many manufacturing jobs overseas, and politics shifting to the right after the stagflation of the 1970s while Fed Chair Paul Volcker’s Federal Reserve raised the Fed Funds rate to 20 percent, causing several recessions .

The loss of manufacturing jobs resulted in a very angry rust-belt populace and a huge surge in drug use and suicides among white males living there that was first documented in the best-selling Deaths of Despair and the Future of Capitalism by Nobel Laureate Angus Deaton and his wife, Ann Case.

The result is the share of Americans still living middle class lives in 2023 has shrunk to 51 percent from 61 percent in 1971 due to the loss of those jobs as well as Republican legislatures and the Supreme Court limiting labor unions’ collective bargaining power to replace them.

PEW

The loss of incomes and jobs led to the current economic divide, GW Bush’s war on drugs and the highest incarceration rate in the world. The hollowed out American middle class became a predominantly consumer society living on cheaper imports mostly employed in lower paying service sector jobs, whether as professionals in high tech or recreation and leisure activities.

Best-selling author Robert Putnam in Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community attributed the growing political divide to the consequent breakup of communities as they moved away from their birthplace or original communities in search of better jobs.

Whereas our neighbor Canada with a similar population mix had greater income equality by maintaining a predominately middle-class society, in part because it had strong labor unions. A 2023 Pollara survey of 3,000 Canadians 18 and older found that a much larger 78 per cent of Canadians consider themselves middle class, including 39 per cent of those earning less than $20,000, and 92 per cent of those earning more than $150,000.

Australia with a similar population mix is also considered a much more egalitarian society. Approximately 56 percent of the population self-identify as middle class, while 43 percent identify as working class and 1.4 percent as upper class. Other surveys suggest that around 58 percent of the population is in the middle-income class. The HILDA survey indicates that a significant portion, roughly 80 percent, of Australians are classified as middle class based on one measure.

Just the fact that most of their inhabitants considered themselves in the middle-class contributed to their sense of wellbeing.

We can also begin to restore our sense of wellbeing by growing our middle class once again with a simple but profound change—heeding Governor Shapiro’s appeal to find political leaders who will work to raise the national minimum wage above $7.25 per hour that was last raised in 2009.

Many of the poorest red states in the south and Midwest rust belt don’t even have a minimum wage, so they must adhere to our national minimum wage. Yet we know blue states such as California and New York have raised their minimum wage above $15 per hour, attracting a more creative and productive work force.

Working towards greater income equality that other developed countries have maintained with a strong middle class would help to bring Americans together again.

“William Penn founded our commonwealth as a place where all would be welcome — a place of tolerance and understanding where people of different faiths could live together in peace,” said Shapiro.

Where better to find such a leader who will take his cues from the good people and listen to our better angels than the Governor of Pennsylvania, in the original home of the Declaration of Independence and U.S. Constitution.

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen