The Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, Personal Consumption Expenditures Index (PCE) isn’t declining because consumers continue to spend more than they earn. Why?
Such spending gave a boost to retail sales and so made holiday shoppers happier. But it also highlighted the underlying problem, inflation is still too high.
The June to December BEA graph shows the difference between income (blue bar) and spending, or outlays (orange bar). It has been this way for at least one year. The declining black line in the graph measures consumers’ personal savings rate, which is back down to 3.8 percent from almost 5 percent in June 2024 because of it.
Why do consumers keep spending more than they make? One clue is that most of the spending is for housing, utilities, transportation and gasoline—necessities. It must be that consumers are not earning enough to keep up with rising prices for their basic needs.
But it also shows a bit if irrational exuberance—a form of excessive optimism that former Fed Chair Greenspan warned about in the ‘90s—and is happening in the financial markets today, which are at record highs.
“The numbers look good. Maybe even surprisingly good—and that’s not a word I throw around willy nilly,” said Barron’s Magazine’s Jack Hough recently about the financial markets.
Stubborn inflation tells us why it became the backbreaker for Democrats in this election cycle. It confirms the most basic of economic laws—the Law of Supply and Demand. The American economy as well as imports are not supplying enough goods and services to satisfy the demand for them.
Most of the inflation surge was in the service sector, as I said, and consumers want more and better services most of all. Hence personal expenditures (blue line in second graph) is hovering around 2.8 percent—too high for the Fed that wants 2 percent inflation.
Inflation in the Fed’s PCE price index for December increased 2.6 percent in one year. Excluding food and energy, the PCE price index increased 2.8 percent from one year ago.
This picture tells us the real problem—the slow recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic isn’t producing enough. World supply has not caught up with the world demand for goods and services. It is also due to so much geopolitical unrest, including the Mideast and Ukraine conflicts.
And the Trump administration wants to deport those undocumented immigrants that mostly work in the services industries, which means more worker shortages; as well as raise tariffs on many countries, which could cut GDP growth by some 1 percent, according to the Peterson Institute, a non-partisan research organization.
It will make everything that American consumers want even more expensive. And that might keep the Federal Reserve from dropping interest rates further, as they hinted in their just concluded January FOMC meeting. How about that?
There was also some good news. The U.S. economy grew at a mild 2.3% annual pace in the final three months of 2024, and the details of the report showed an economy on strong footing that was being handed over to the Trump administration. GDP grew at 3% and 3.1% in the two prior quarters.
It’s still not a good time for excessive optimism, in my opinion.
Harlan Green © 2025
Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen