Too Much Disinflation Is Bad Planning

 Financial FAQs

FREDcapex

The rumblings of an oncoming disinflationary spiral are becoming louder. And it may be as difficult to tame as the current inflationary spike that so worries the Federal Reserve.

What is disinflation as opposed to outright deflation? It’s when prices are still rising but at a lower inflation rate, vs. outright deflation when prices are falling, which occurs during a recession. Deflation last happened during the Great Recession and busted housing bubble.

The COVID pandemic and war in Ukraine have thrown a monkey wrench into economic policy-making because inflation reared up so quickly after the worldwide shutdown of economic activity, when governments and Central Banks spent $trillions in various COVID rescue packages in the face of worldwide shortages of goods and services—especially food and energy sources

The problem is how to cure inflation without causing a recession, since raising interest rates too rapidly harms future economic investment, particularly capital expenditures (capex), as well as consumer spending. Capex investment has abruptly declined after its rapid rise post-COVID, per the above FRED graph.

Adam Tooze, a well-regarded economic historian, is one of the loudest sounding the disinflation alarm in a recent NYTimes Opinion.

“We now find ourselves in the midst of the most comprehensive tightening of monetary policy the world has seen. And raising interest rates is not going to bring more gas or microchips to market, but rather the contrary. Reducing investment will limit capacity and thus reduce future supply”

Former Fed Chair Ben Bernanke, one of three economists just awarded the 2022 Economics Nobel Prize, is contributing to the chorus. He warned that our Fed’s attempt to “fine tune” economic stability risks with interest-rate policies was not a good idea. “I don’t think we understand that well enough, except in perhaps extreme conditions, to try to fine-tune financial stability using monetary policy,” he said when interviewed at the Brookings Institute.

What is our Federal Reserve to do when the Produce Price Index for raw materials and wholesale goods that came out today is still rising? The increase in wholesale prices over the past year is up 8.5 percent, down slightly from 8.7 percent in the prior month. Inflation is still running near a 40-year high.

But prices are already plunging is many areas not covered by the standard inflation indexes. The New York Federal Reserve has said its September Survey of Consumer Expectations found that respondents projected their spending will rise by 6 percent over the next year, a sharp drop from the 7.8 percent rise predicted in the August survey. The bank noted that decline in spending expectations was the biggest since the survey began in 2013, while inflation expectations are holding steady, even declining slightly in the near term.

Adam Tooze’s plea echoes what many economic planners worry about. It’s taken more than two years to bring the COVID pandemic under control. Why not give the world’s economies more time to recover?

Harlan Green © 2022

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen