What is Worrying Consumers?

 Financial FAQs

 “Consumer confidence tumbled in November to its second lowest level since April after moving sideways for several months,” said Dana M Peterson, Chief Economist, The Conference Board. “All five components of the overall index flagged or remained weak.”

Conference Board

Why are consumers worrying so much? Maybe they don’t like government shutdowns? Or, maybe it’s because higher prices and the tariffs are hurting small businesses that depend on imported goods? Or, there are fewer available jobs. Actually, it’s all of the above per the Conference Board’s Consumer Confidence Survey.

“Consumers’ write-in responses pertaining to factors affecting the economy continued to be led by references to prices and inflation, tariffs and trade, and politics, with increased mentions of the federal government shutdown.”

It’s also becoming obvious that consumers don’t like bully behavior, such as Republicans ramming through the continuing budget resolution without Democrats’ input.

Republicans were in fact attempting to take down Obamacare (ACA) once again by not including the subsidies in the continuing resolution that made it available for middle and low-income folk, I said last week.

Retail sales data finally released for September showed consumers were still shopping and dining out, but not as much.

So what will happen now? This was all before the shutdown. My guesstimate with anecdotal evidence from the likes of Walmart, Target, et. al., is that the more affluent consumers that own homes and stocks will come storming out of the gates after the shutdown and maybe party through the holidays. Government workers will be receiving extra paydays, for instance—i.e., weeks of backpay.

Doug McMillon, Walmart’s outgoing chief executive, cited by MarketWatch, said on the chain’s earnings call that middle-and-upper-income households drove growth in the U.S. during the third quarter. He also said that “lower-income families have been under additional pressure of late.”

And the financial markets have been rallying as it looks like the Fed will cut rates once again in December. Consumers will rally as well as they race to borrow and purchase during the holidays. That’s because polls say they expect inflation to surge over the next year when things will become more expensive.

And Trump has grown wilier with his tariff pronouncements, not touting their benefits so loudly, for instance, which was alarming consumers, while finally admitting that tariffs have been raising prices. His MAGA followers are suffering the most. He must have finally looked at his poor poll numbers that are even lower than during his first term.

The other unspoken shoe to drop that affects consumers is the shrinking job market. ADP payrolls reports that just +42,000 private payrolls were added in October. Trade, Transportation, Education and Healthcare added the most jobs. But -51,000 jobs were lost in other sectors such as Information and Information and business services.

“Private employers added jobs in October for the first time since July, but hiring was modest relative to what we reported earlier this year. Meanwhile, pay growth has been largely flat for more than a year, indicating that shifts in supply and demand are balanced,” said Dr. Nela Richardson, Chief Economist

It’s pretty obvious that we are living in uncertain times, and the old Republican playbook of tax cuts combined with DOGE and Project 25 slashing of government benefits isn’t yet hurting the 10 percent of consumers that have assets, but that leaves 90 percent of Americans still living paycheck to paycheck.

What will happen to them?

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen

Good September Unemployment Report

 

Popular Economics Weekly

“…while the economy is growing thanks to AI spending, it’s a K-shaped expansion: People who were already affluent are becoming more so, but the less well-off are under severe pressure.” Paul Krugman

FREDnonfarmpayrolls

The delayed U.S. unemployment report for September was good old news. It showed 119,000 nonfarm payroll jobs were created, though the unemployment rate edged up to 4.4%. But that was before the government shutdown.

And the U.S. had already lost -13,000 nonfarm payroll jobs in June and -4,000 jobs in August. The U.S. economy has averaged just 38,600 new jobs per month through September since Trump announced the April 2 retaliatory tariffs, as employers haven’t been hiring while they wait see what the final tariff rates (and therefore costs) might be.

The October employment report has been canceled because of the government shutdown and the November report will come out late, depriving the Federal Reserve of critical information before its next meeting to decide whether to cut interest rates again. Both reports were postponed by the 43-day government shutdown that lasted from Oct. 1 to Nov. 12.

So the November employment report will be published on Dec. 16 instead of Dec. 5 as originally scheduled, per the BLS. An estimate of employment for October will be included in the November jobs report. It’s thought that up to 100,000 more government jobs may have been lost in October due to firings or attrition.

It is a K-shaped jobs report, as Nobel Laureate Krugman stated. This is why hiring has stagnated at such a low level since April. Jobs are being created in the lower-paying service sector, whereas the industrial sector and governments are losing jobs.

Employment in food services and drinking places continued to trend up in September (+37,000). In September, social assistance employment continued to trend up (+14,000), reflecting continued job growth in individual and family services (+20,000).

Employment in transportation and warehousing declined by 25,000 in September as job losses occurred in warehousing and storage (-11,000) and couriers and messengers (-7,000). Federal government employment continued to decline in September (-3,000) and is down by 97,000 since reaching a peak in January.

That means the more affluent consumers continued to dine out and could afford more health care services, which is now the fastest growing segment of the economy, as I said.

So the economy is k-shaped because just 10 percent of American consumers are keeping the economy from contracting, because they now own more than 50 percent of assets, according the latest Federal Reserve data—in housing, pensions, and financial assets. And the stock market is still booming.

But small businesses that employ the most workers aren’t hiring because more than 90 percent of them are dependent on imported goods that Trump has targeted with his higher tariffs. We won’t see its effect on economic growth until the fourth quarter and beyond.

If employers aren’t hiring, what is causing the predictions for 4 percent GDP growth in Q3? It’s a statistical fluke because imports are deducted from exports and other domestic expenditures to calculate the overall GDP growth rate. And small business importers are buying less at the moment. The Gross Domestic Product measures what is produced domestically, in other words.

This is the k-shaped economy we will have to live with. The NYTimes reports that the unemployment rate for 20-24 year-olds has risen to 9.2 percent. The hiring slowdown means they are competing with more experienced workers for fewer available jobs, at least until the tariff rates have settled.

Interest rates? The Fed is scheduled to cut rates another -0.25 percent in December but what if inflation doesn’t come down? Trump has signaled he wants to continue to lower interest rates regardless of the consequences.

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen

Who Won the Shutdown?

 Financial FAQs

“What if conservatives succeeded in repealing Obamacare? “Republicans' Obamacare repeal bill would leave 17 million more people uninsured next year, and 32 million more in 2026, the Congressional Budget Office said in an estimate Wednesday. It also said premiums would double by 2026. …By 2026, three quarters of the population would live in areas with no insurers participating in the non-group market, due to upward pressure on premiums and downward pressure on enrollment, the report found.” Huffington Post

GETTYIMAGES

Republicans didn’t win the recent government shutdown because they don’t understand how important affordable healthcare has become to all Americans, not just the wealthy.

They were in fact attempting to take down Obamacare (ACA) once again by not including the subsidies in the continuing resolution that made it available for middle and low-income folk.

Republicans have proven time and again that they want non-senior Americans to pay for health care out of their own pockets, if not through their employer or business. Their extreme dislike of the federal government providing any public healthcare is most evident in Trump picking a very demented RFK, Jr. to lead the Department of Health & Human Services, while slashing Medicare and Medicaid benefits.

It reveals why they are the party of wealthy oligarchs. They are not at all interested in the health of their constituents. It’s why Republican administrations have attempted to repeal Obamacare more than 30 times and why many of the Republican red states haven’t enlisted in the Obamacare premium subsidies that would enable their own citizens to afford Obamacare

So I cited above a CBO estimate from my 2017 Huffington Post article of the benefits to Americans’ health from Obamacare resulting from its passage.

A 2016 Commonwealth Club study said “…evidence indicates that the ACA has likely acted as an economic stimulus, in part by freeing up private and public resources for investment in jobs and production capacity. Moreover, the law’s payment and other cost-related reforms appear to have contributed to the marked slowdown in health spending growth seen in recent years.”

Some of those benefits are:

· Health care spending growth per person—both public and private—has slowed for five years.

· A number of ACA reforms, particularly related to Medicare, have likely contributed to the slowdown in health care spending growth by tightening provider payment rates and introducing incentives to reduce excess costs.

· Faster-than-expected economic growth and slower-than-expected health care spending have led to multiple downward revisions of the federal deficit and projected deficits.

· These trends have also been a boon to state and local government budgets, as job growth has improved state tax revenues while cost growth in health care programs has slowed. At the same time, expanding insurance to millions of people who were previously uninsured has supported local health systems and enhanced families’ ability to pay for necessities, including health care.

We now must wait for the November 20 release of the delayed September unemployment report to learn just how much the shutdown hurt the American economy.

But the almost complete ignorance of Obamacare’s importance by Republicans during the shutdown enabled Democrats’ big win in the November elections.

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen

U.S. Economy Is Freezing!

 Popular Economics Weekly

“…while the economy is growing thanks to AI spending, it’s a K-shaped expansion: People who were already affluent are becoming more so, but the less well-off are under severe pressure. For example, there are clear signs that middle-to-low income consumers are struggling: car loan and credit card delinquencies are rising, and grocers report that shoppers are buying cheaper varieties of food. At the same time, the affluent are spending freely: the top 10% of the income distribution now accounts for nearly half of all consumer spending.” Paul Krugman

PBS.org

This was the wrong season for President Trump’s Republicans to freeze Democrats out of the just passed continuing resolution or demolish the East Wing. We already have a record fall freeze hitting the Midwest and southern states.

Americans already feeling the freeze is also a good way to describe the Democrats landslide victories in the November elections. The record government shutdown put the U.S. economy on pause, but in fact much of the damage was already done, says Nobel Laureat Paul Krugman, just as Trump seemed oblivious to the timing of the damage being done to the White House,.

Republicans had been losing in the popularity polls this year because they chose to ignore the signs. So they believed that flying blind by keeping the federal government closed without official economic data on employment and inflation was the better option than knowing the truth.

But there are other data to fill the government void in data collecting that affect how consumers behave. The ADP, for instance, a private sector payment provider said private-sector employers shed an average of 11,250 jobs a week in the four weeks ending Oct. 25.

This hit the “middle-to-low income” consumers particularly hard that Krugman is talking about. What about inflation?

Ordinary grocery prices are climbing, forcing consumers to shop for “cheaper varieties of food.” Grocery prices have risen 18.2 percent since January 2022, making a $100 grocery bill approximately $118 today, per CBS News.

And President Trump is flailing in his attempt to mask the damage his tariff war is causing. Overall consumer inflation is stuck at 3 percent in large part because of the tariffs, so he wants to offer $2,000 rebates to consumers while the Fed is cutting interest rates. This would cost more than the import taxes he has already collected, enlarging the federal debt that has ballooned from his Big Beautiful Bill tax cuts.

And his proposed cuts to legal immigration from the longer term, historical average of one million to 7500 annually, will continue to shrink the workforce, even the number of H-1B work visas for highly qualified workers that are badly needed in the tech sector.

All of this will continue to damage economic growth at a time when worldwide economic growth is being affected by the chaos Trump has generated in tearing up existing foreign trade agreements.

No economy can tolerate such uncertain weather over the longer term. Hence investment decisions remain frozen while consumers find shelter for the coming economic winter. How severe will it be?

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen

Why Make America Weak?

 

Financial FAQs

“This great Nation will endure as it has endured, will revive and will prosper. So, first of all, let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear itself—nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advance.” Franklin Delano Rooselvelt

theguardian.com

The Democrat’s election sweep on November 2 is proving that American voters  heeded President Roosevelt’s famous warning at his first inaugural address, that the Democrats' paralysis after the loss to Trump II is over and fear, the greatest enemy of Democracy, can be conquered.

The November 2 elections showed just how illusory were those fears that Donald Trump and Republicans wanted Americans to believe, that the largest, most prosperous country in the world had grown weak. Americans were now in danger and only he and his oligarchs could save US.

In fact, Donald Trump and the Republican Party have been attempting to weaken everything that makes America the oldest constitutional democracy since his first day in office.

He began by slashing of essential government services via Elon Musk’s DOGE computer hackers (such as social security, Medicare, Medicare) that benefit all Americans, the attempt to eliminate the the Department of Education that supports our basic universal K-12 and early childhood educational systems, while picking the most unqualified to run the FBI, Department of Homeland Services, and Health and Human Services so that they are no longer fully functional. 

The brutal roundup of undocumented immigrants, whether they have a criminal record, are decimating the ranks of workers that fill agricultural, manufacturing, and service sector jobs needed to maintain economic growth.

The biggest financial threat to ordinary Americans are the rising prices on basic necessities that most Americans depend on due to tariff rates now at Great Depression levels, impoverishing the majority of Americans that live from paycheck-to-paycheck.

It’s become obvious that the Trump administration’s intent has been to instill as much fear as possible in the most vulnerable Americans that the federal government won’t work for them and only Trump and his oligarchs can same them.

But the recent election and huge protests at the last No Kings rallies are a sign that millions of Americans haven’t been cowed or paralyzed.

In fact, they have said, as did Howard Beale, the News Anchor in the movie Network, “I’m as mad as hell and not going to take this anymore!”

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen

Are We Flying Blind?

 Popular Economics Weekly

"The United States economy is like a poker game where the chips have become concentrated in fewer and fewer hands, and where the other fellows can stay in the game only by borrowing. When their credit runs out the game will stop." Marriner Eccles

 

wallpaperaccess.com

The famous above quote by Roosevelt’s Federal Reserve Chairman, Marriner Eccles on what he believed caused the Great Depression is a warning that the U.S. economy is now flying blind during this government shutdown.

Eccles should know. He guided Federal Reserve policy during the Great Depression that implemented the New Deal.

Economic downturns occur when consumers are tapped out and begin to borrow more than they spend. It is the reason that retail sales and consumer confidence surveys are important signs of whether consumers will continue to shop, or drop, as the saying goes.

And given the economic chaos being sown by the Trump administration during what looks like a record government shutdown, we don’t have any official data being released on when it might happen and what it will look like. So we are flying blind.

There are past recessions that economists look at; the Dot-com bubble that burst in 2001 from over investment in fiber optics that didn’t pan out immediately because it took years for the Internet to be adopted. Now there is over-investment in AI that could follow the same path as the so-called Dot-com recession.

And the Great Depression was largely due to the Herbert Hoover administration allowing tariff rates to rise to unacceptable levels that choked off foreign trade on which many countries, including America, relied on.

There was also the too easy credit conditions of the “Roaring Twenties” that weren’t regulated yet, which allowed the American public to borrow and invest in the stock market for the first time. The October 1929 “Black Friday” market crash followed that precipitated the Great Depression.

So we can take our pick: Trump’s too high tariffs, or too little market regulation allowing shadow lending markets (or junk bonds) to flourish outside of regulated lending channels might cause the next downturn.

Trump’s newest Federal Reserve pick, and former chief economic advisor, Stephen Miran, is even sounding the alarm in calling for larger Federal Reserve rate cuts.

“If you keep policy this tight for a long period of time, then you run the risk that monetary policy itself is inducing a recession,” Miran said in a recent interview cited by the NYTimes.

Another danger sign is The Institute for Supply Management’s (ISM) latest report that American manufacturers contracted for the eighth month in a row with no end in sight because of the Trump administration tariffs, reports MarketWatch, which cited several anecdotes in the ISM Manufacturing report.

“Business continues to be severely depressed. Profits are down and extreme taxes (tariffs) are being shouldered by all companies in our space,” said one executive at a maker of transportation equipment.

“Steel tariffs are killing us,” another manufacturer told ISM.

“The tariffs are still causing issues with imported goods into the U.S.,” an executive at a chemical maker said. “The inflation issues continue.”

The closely followed manufacturing index slipped to 48.7% in October from 49.1% in the prior month, the Institute for Supply Management said Monday. Any number below 50% signals contraction.

I’ve already reported that consumers are feeling less confident in the University of Michigan Sentiment survey.

“Consumers continue to express frustration over the persistence of high prices, with 44% spontaneously mentioning that high prices are eroding their personal finances, the highest reading in a year. Interviews this month highlight the fact that consumers feel pressure both from the prospect of higher inflation as well as the risk of weaker labor markets,” said Survey Director Joanne Hsu

The real danger is that we are gleaning all these signs from industry reports outside of the ‘official’ government reports on employment, inflation, and consumer spending just before the holidays.

So, the U.S. economy is flying blind without the usual flight data that tells us where we are headed. Is there a soft landing, or crash landing ahead?

Harlan Green © 2025

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HarlanGreen